|
Papponymy is the custom of naming a child after a deceased
(or living) ancestor or a person influential in one's life. In the Book of Mormon this practice is quite
common. The discoveries at Elephantine support the Book of Mormon's position that
papponymy was a common occurrence among fifth-sixth century BC Jews and
Israelites. Chart 1, is an example
of papponymy as constructed from a family archive at Elephantine.
"This custom was frequent during that time period among Jews, Persians, [Early
and Late] Babylonian's Phoenicians, and
Egyptians, even non-Jews at Elephantine...these Aramaic-speaking Jews of Egypt
were for the most part content to draw on a stock of traditional names brought
by their ancestors from Palestine, instead of creating new ones...." (Porten pp.
236-238) Did the Jaredites and Nephites do the same thing? We have no knowledge of what kind of
ancestral records the Jaredites had, though it may be concluded they had
records going back to Adam(Eth 1:3). Names that occur in the Biblical record down
until the time of the Flood and shortly after are reflected in the Jaredite
Record. In the record of the posterity of Jared such names as Noah and Nimrod (the
ninth and twelfth descendants of Jared) would have been known at the time of
the Tower of Babel before the Jaredites left. Nimrod the grandson of Ham built Babel. Other names such
as Levi (twenty-eighth descendent of Jared) and Aaron (thirty-fourth descendent
of Jared) require some investigation. The Nephites had the Brass Plates and
family records to draw from, and after the integration of the Mulekites or the
People of Zarahemla, into the Nephites, the limited records of the Jaredites,
translated by Mosiah, (Omni 1:20) would
also have been available, and as presented below, some names seem to have been
derived from just this source.
Since the Nephites had the Plates of Brass they could have
extracted names from the plates for any time period from Jeremiah back to Adam to
bestow on their children as seen in Chart
2. After Mosiah translated the twenty-four gold plates of Ether (92 BC) any
names those plates contained could have become available. They may also have
used names of known ancestors from the Book of Mormon time period with no known
biblical counterpart (see Chart
3). In the Book of Mormon as well as in the
Elephantine papyri, the practice was also extended to naming the child
after a
living progenitor. According to Porten: "a grandfather moving into his
middle years
or a great-grandfather moving into his late years, would have
experienced a sense
of rejuvenation in seeing a new born baby carry his name." (Porten p.
236).
Einar has a photograph of him as a very little boy being held by his
great-grandfather, Einar, after whom he was named. This also
occurred in the Book of Mormon. It should be noted that given the
Chronology
of the Book of Mormon (Largey pp. 200-201) there were very few records
kept in
detail after 420 BC. For whatever purpose Mormon abridged selective
records and
did not find much that he was inspired to abridge in the records that
followed
420 BC down until about 200 BC when the Book of Mosiah is introduced. A
very
brief series of statements found in Jarom (361 BC) down to King
Benjamin (130
BC) contain little name information, so for nearly three hundred years
there is
an information and record gap in the Book of Mormon. Most of the
Book of Mormon names therefore
come from the records, essentially kept by Nephi and his brothers and
their
sons down to 361, and then from the extensive records incorporated into
the
abridgements by Mormon after 130 BC and later by Moroni who included
the Jaredite Book of
Ether. There could have been families perpetuating names through that
time
period that later showed up in the records from 200 BC to 421 AD.
There are several examples in the Book of Mormon of
papponymy which give us some insight into the importance placed on names by the
Nephites. The two examples explored here deal with two loving fathers—Heleman
and Mormon—naming their sons after righteous men from the past.
The first example is Helaman, the son of Helaman, who lived
during an extremely difficult period in the history of the Nephites (about 52
BC) . As noted in CHART 2, The name Helaman was given first, as far as the
present records are concerned, by Benjamin to his Son, Helaman. The eldest son of Alma, keeper of sacred records, the
interpreters, and the Liohona, high priest and military leader was also named Helaman, and the third Helaman was the son of Helaman the grandson of Alma. This great family
set a lot store on this name. Had some illustrious ancestor carried that name
years before in records not now available? As recorded in the Book of Helaman,
he was appointed to the judgment seat by the voice of the people. He had
replaced Pahoran who was murdered (about
52 BC) by Kishkumen. There was an attempt to kill Helaman also by Kishkumen
(Hel 2:3) In the midst of all this
contention, Helaman had as least two sons. The Book of Mormon records in Helaman 3:21:
"And it came to pass that he had two sons. He gave unto the eldest the name of NEPHI, and unto the youngest, the name
of LEHI. And they began to grow up unto
the Lord." Helaman must have had access
to the Plates of Lehi and Nephi. We can assume that he read them for he knew of
the greatness inherent in Father Lehi and his son, Nephi. Like any loving
father, Helaman desperately wanted righteous sons. The previous chief judge,
Pahoran, had many sons who contended against each other for the power of the
judgment seat; most of whom probably lost their eternal inheritance (see Helaman
Chapter l), this is not the life that Helaman desired for his own two sons.
Searching further into the Book of Helaman it becomes
evident that Helaman was successful in attaining the goal of a righteous
posterity: "And it came to pass that He [Nephi] had become weary because of their [the
people's] iniquity; and he yielded up that judgment seat, and took it upon himself
to preach the word of God all the remainder of his days, and his brother LEHI also, all the remainder of his
days; for they remembered the words
which their father Helaman spake unto them. And these are the words which he
spake: Behold my sons, I desire that ye should remember to keep the commandments of God and I would that ye should
declare unto the people these words. Behold, I have given unto you the names of
our first parents who came out of the land of Jerusalem: and this I had done
that when you remember your names ye
may remember them; and when ye remember
them ye may remember their works;
and when ye remember their works ye may
know how that it is said, and also written, that they were good. Therefore, my
sons, I would that ye should do that which is good, that it may be said of you,
and also written, even as it has been said and written of them." (Hel 5:6-7) Most
certainly, as well as for other purposes, names were given for remembrance, a potent reminder!
Here it is evident that a loving father had taught his sons
well to live the gospel. Part of that teaching included bestowing upon his sons
the names of righteous progenitor prophets.
This is perhaps one of the most exquisite usages of this aspect of papponymy
found in the scriptures.
A second example of papponymy occurs later in the Book of Mormon.
In the declining years of the Nephites, Mormon acted as their most influential
military leader. We read in Mormon 2:1, "And it came to pass in that same year
there began to be a war between the Nephites and the Lamanites. And not-withstanding I being young, was large
in stature; therefore the people of Nephi appointed me that I should be their
leader, or the leader of their armies." Mormon as a young boy of fifteen he had
seen the Savior (Mor 1:15). After this experience he records, "And I did
endeavor to preach unto this people, but my mouth was shut, and I was forbidden
that I should preach unto them; for they had willfully rebelled against their
God; and the beloved disciples were taken away out of the land, because of
their iniquity. But I did remain among them, but I was forbidden to preach unto
them, because of the hardness of their hearts; and because of the hardness of
their hearts the land was cursed for their sake." (Mor 1:16)
Perhaps Mormon's greatest contribution to us was his
abridgement of many of the records available to him into the sacred writing we now
possess as the Book of Mormon. Do you
ever wonder just how Mormon selected from among all the available plates the
short abridged history and doctrine we have. Ty found as a teen-ager in Seminary
there were certain sections of the Book of Mormon that were difficult to
read. Why are they there? For example so
many pages devoted to the wars and contentions at approximately 70 BC. Twenty chapters in the Book of Alma,
comprising fully ten per cent of the entire Book of Mormon cover twenty years,
merely two percent of Nephite history. Perhaps one possible reason for
incorporating this material is in a latter section of Alma. He has one central character, Moroni, likely the
greatest military leader of the Nephites. Mormon was a commander of armies and
must have enjoyed the strategies employed by his predecessor. Even more
importantly though, place yourself into Mormon's life. Here was a young prophet
general who lived a very a personal spiritual life amidst the wickedness and
military struggles of the day, and had a son to raise.
When Mormon was blessed with a son, the spiritual climate
was still that of rebellion. The wickedness of the people was intense. How
could one raise a family in this environment without fearing apostasy among his
children. He must have been very
concerned for the eternal welfare of that child. As a soldier Mormon recognized that at any
moment his life could end on some battle field leaving a son without a father
to pattern his life after. Was it that as
Mormon was compiling the Book of Mormon he was impressed with Moroni, one who could engage in military
struggles while maintaining righteousness?
He therefore named his son after this successful general hoping that his
son would emulate Moroni
of old. Mormon knew that his son would read the records on the gold plates and
if he was not there to be the father maybe his ancestor could surrogate for him
by proxy. After all, Mormon himself had
emulated the earlier Moroni!
Mormon realized that he would not be able to reconvert his
people back to the doctrines of Christ, and because of their hardness of heart his
preaching would unlikely be successful either. So, the last hope was to try and
maintain military advantage over the Lamanites until possibly their hearts
would soften sometime in the future. Thus, he named his son Moroni so that he might
emulate the prior Moroni and grow up to be a righteous,
valiant general in the Nephite army, but always serving the Lord.
Mormon's hope for the people's repentance faded as recorded
in Mormon 2:12-14: "And it came to pass that when I Mormon, saw their
lamentation and their mourning and their sorrow before the Lord, my heart did
begin to rejoice within me, knowing the mercies and the long-suffering of the
Lord, therefore supposing that he would be merciful unto them that they would
again become righteous people. But behold this my joy was in vain, for their
sorrowing was not unto repentance, because of the goodness of God; but it was
rather the sorrowing of the damned, because the Lord would not always suffer
them to take happiness in sin. And they did not come unto Jesus with broken hearts
and contrite spirits, but they did curse God, and wish to die, nevertheless
they would struggle with the sword for their lives.
Though wounded in the great battle, it was not until later
that Mormon was slain. (Mormon 8:3). His son, Moroni, lived up to the greatness expected of
him and honored the name that had been bestowed on him by his father. Near the
end of his life and after a long journey he deposited the records in the Hill Cumorah
(at New York)
and later, as a resurrected being, was given the sacred responsibility of delivering
those records to Joseph Smith at the same hill.
Examination of CHART
4, reveals that the custom of papponymy was also
common among the Jaredites. At least ten
examples can be found in the Book of Ether. An exhaustive listing is found
in CHART 4. Even more interesting, though, is the possibility
that the Nephites extracted names from the twenty-four plates of gold, written
by Ether, the last prophet of the Jaredites, and found in the Land of Desolation.
We will term this cross-cultural papponymy and there may be more
examples. (see CHART 5)
Two of the names, Aaron
and Noah, are also found on the Brass plates and may reflect extraction from
that source rather than the Jaredite records, though both names appear in the
genealogy of Jared, which suggests some names have an extended history. Two others are discussed below.
Around 120 BC an expedition originally looking for the land of Zarahemla became lost in the land
northward and found evidence of another civilization destroyed by
internecine wars. This is exactly as
described for America's
First Civilization, the Olmecs. (Benson 1968)
Among other items twenty four
plates with engravings were found. The
excitement caused by these plates can be felt in the following passage from
Mosiah 8:12, "And I say unto thee again: Knowest thou of any one that can translate?
For I am desirous that these records should be translated into our language;
for perhaps, they will give us a knowledge of a remnant of the people who have
been destroyed, from whence these records came; or, perhaps, they will give us
a knowledge of this very people who
have been destroyed; and I am
desirous to know the cause of their destruction." They were translated by King Mosiah and were
probably made available to the people. One of the names on those plates was Morianton, a Jaredite King, the twenty-sixth
descendant of Jared, over a millennium before. Approximately fifty years later
in Alma (Alma
50:28) we find a Nephite who also carries the exact same name: Morianton. It is interesting to speculate that his
parents may have been alive about the time of the discovery of the twenty-four gold
plates, which they may have had access to, and named their son after the ancient Jaredite
King. Since the name Morianton is
not found in the Bible it is unlikely that they could have extracted the name
from the Brass Plates of Laban. It is also
unlikely that they would have independently derived the exact name themselves. But
might some ancient source now discovered or to be discovered, after the time of
the Jaredites left the region of the Tower of Babel contain that name?
The second example involves the name Shiblom. It first appears as a late Jaredite King in Ether l:11,
the thirty-eighth descendent of Jared. The exact name is also held by a Nephite
commander of armies about 385 AD almost two thousand years later. Both names did not appear in the Nephite
vernacular until after the discovery of the twenty-four Jaredite gold plates.
Although one cannot definitely substantiate the above associations it is an interesting
speculation of possible cross-cultural, Jaredite to Nephite, papponymy.
Examination of the charts in this research will demonstrates
that papponymy was prolific in the Book
of Mormon, both among the Nephites and the Jaredites; remarkably consistent
with a large array of contemporary documents coming to light in our
generation. Papponymy as found in the Book of Mormon, though, was not limited
to just honoring the deceased ancestor, or historical figure or place, but as a
powerful tool in promoting righteousness and self-esteem among the children.
When we reflect on Joseph Smith, how
meaningful it is to know that he bore not only his father's name but also the name
of Joseph of Old. Significantly, his
own name in Hebrew means "'he who gathers', or he who will ‘cause to return,'
or appropriately, ‘God gathereth'." (McConkie p. 157)
Now let us look at an unusual Elephantine Papponymy:
|
|
CHART l |
|
|
ELEPHANTINE PAPPONYMY |
|
THE HOUSE OF MAHSEIAH |
|
|
JEDANIAH |
|
|
|
MAHSEIAH |
|
|
JEDANIAH |
GEMARIAH |
MIBTAHIAH |
|
|
JEDANIAH MAHSEIAH |
|
|
JEDANIAH MAHSEIAH |
The above tabulated names are part of the Family of Mahseiah b. (son of) Jedaniah, in Elephantine.
Mibtahiah was a granddaughter of Jedaniah. About 471 BC Mibtahiah had the archive of the family
that had been passed down to her, three more documents were added by her
children, and showed that the archive passed to them upon her death. (Porten p.
239). The papponymy is almost taken to
an extreme. The first listed in the
archive is Jedaniah who had a son named
Mahseiah. Mahseiah
had two sons, one he named Jedaniah
after his father, the other he named Gemariah.
And he had a daughter he named Mibtahiah.
Gemariah had three sons, the third
son he named Jedaniah, after his
grandfather. Gemariah also had a
daughter he named Miptahiah which also
became or may have been a family name. Mibtahiah, the daughter of Mahseiah, had two sons by her first
Husband, Jezaniah [she married him in
460 BC]. She named one son after her grandfather, Jedaniah, and her other son after her father Mahseiah. Mibtahiah survived three husbands, and
died in 416 BC. To a daughter by her third husband (Ashor) she gave her own
name, Mibtahiah. Her name may also
have been and old family name. She also had two sons by her third husband, and
she named them Jedaniah and Mahseiah
after her ancestors. Her
second husband gave their children biblical names which may have been
family
names for him. The details provide an interesting reading because of
the lands
and properties that were dispersed among the children. (Porten p.
240-242). Most interesting is that the land and properties
were right across the road from the Temple
to YHW built on Elephantine by the
Jewish Mercenaries. Note that all of the names of both sons and daughters
carried the suffix (and hypocoristicon) of -iah, short-hand for Jehovah, found in some Book of Mormon
names. Many Book of Mormon names also have the variation of -iah in the form of -i h ah, i.e. Zemnarihah
(the appointed leader of the Gidianton Robbers, 3 Ne 4:14-17 about 21 AD).
Mibtahiah's family was of
prominent lineage. (Porten p. 237) They
were apparently faithful worshippers of Jehovah.
In another instance, found in Elephantine;
two brothers giving their sons the same name as their father.
There are also at Elephantine
twenty-two examples of a grandson being given the name of his grandfather such
as:
GRANDFATHERS NAMES: Zaccur
Acho
Hazzul Shallum
GRANDSON'S NAMES:
Zaccur
Acho Hazzul
Shallum
An unusual papponymy involves different spelling of the
name: Hosea b. (son of) Zaccur, Hoshaiah b. Jathom, Hosea
b. Harman b. Osea, Hosea b. Zaccur b. Oshaiah(Porten p. 235-236) Also, Zephaniah b.
Zaccur b. Zephaniah is another
grandfather to grandson. (Porten pp. 236) The ‘b.' stands for ‘son of.'
Extensive papponymy
is also found in Egypt
as any one would see in tracing the names of Pharaohs chronologically. During the Saitic Dynasties, of particular
interest, in which time the Jewish settlement at Elephantine and the Temple were built,
Egyptian papponymy was very common. The Saitic Kings also practiced papponymy: Psammetichus 1, Psammetichus 11,
Necho 1, Necho 11, etc. Amytaeus, one of the rulers during the time the Jewish temple was
destroyed and rebuilt at Elephantine, was the
grandson of Amytaeus who
collaborated with Inaros in the revolt of 463 BC. (Porten p. 236). In Assyria, papponymy
was also common, the name of Ashur-dan was repeated many times from 1179
BC to 754 BC. Sargon was also repeated
many times from 2300 BC to at least 721 BC. (Saggs pp. 418-419) In Babylonia names were also repeated such as Nabu-nasir (746-734 BC). In Urartu, [of interest because it is
another source of name parallels] the same practice was followed such as the name
Rusas repeatedly given to later generations. (Saggs
p. 419) All of these were Semitic
languages and followed similar Onomastic
rules. All of this was common practice before
and after Lehi's sojourn in Jerusalem. Joseph Smith could not have imagined this was
the case.
CHART 2, provides a list of Nephite Papponymy from Lehi 600 BC to
Moroni 421 AD. Some dates both BC and Ad are provided for
Chronological purposes, and then names are provided from different
times throughout the 1000 year history
of the Nephites, with some references and sometimes a comment on who
they were.
|
|
CHART 2 |
|
|
|
NEPHITE PAPPONYMY |
|
|
Alma |
Helman |
Laman |
|
Mos
17:3 |
Mos 1:2 |
l Nep. 2:5 |
|
173 BC |
130 BC |
600 BC |
|
Founder of Church |
Son of K. Benjamin |
Son of Lehi |
|
Alma |
Helaman |
Laman |
|
Mos 27:8 |
Al 31:7 |
Lamanite king |
|
100 BC |
74 BC |
Mos 10:6 |
|
Son of Alma |
Son of Alma |
178 BC |
|
|
|
Laman's son |
|
Moroni |
Helaman |
Laman |
|
Al 43: 16 |
Mos 63:11 |
63 BC |
|
100 BC |
53 BC |
Nephite Soldier |
|
Righteous General |
S of Helaman |
|
|
Father of Mornihah |
Chief Judge |
Lachoneus |
|
|
|
3 N 1:1 |
|
Moronihah |
Mormon |
1 AD |
|
Al 62:43 |
Mor 1:5 |
Chief Judge |
|
60 BC |
322 AD |
Lachoneus |
|
Son of Moroni |
Father of Mormon |
3 Ne 6:19 |
|
Moronihah |
|
29 AD |
|
Morm 6:14 |
Mormon |
Son of Above |
|
385 AD |
W of M. 1:1 |
|
|
Nephite General |
333 AD |
Mosiah |
|
|
General/Prophet |
Omni 1:12 |
|
Moroni |
Abridger of B of M |
154 BC |
|
W of M 1:1 |
|
Prophet/King |
|
421 AD |
Nephi |
|
|
Son of Mormon |
1 Ne 1:1 |
Mosiah |
|
Last Nephite |
600 BC |
Mos 1:2 |
|
|
Son of Lehi |
100 BC |
|
Pahoran |
Nephi (2) |
Grandson of King Mosiah
|
|
Alma 50:39 |
Hel 3:21 |
|
|
68 BC |
45 BC |
|
|
Third Ch. Judge |
Son of Helaman |
Zoram |
|
Pahoran |
Nephi (3) |
1 Neph 4:20 |
|
Hel 1:3 |
3 Nep l:2 |
600 BC |
|
52 BC |
Son of Nephi |
Servant of Laban |
|
Son of Pahoran |
One of Twelve |
Zoram |
|
Fourth Judge |
Translated |
Al 16:5 |
|
|
Nephi (4) |
81 BC |
|
Lehi
(1) |
1 AD |
Nephite Captain |
|
600 BC |
4 Neph 1:19 |
Zoram |
|
Prophet Leader |
Son of above |
Al 1-:59 |
|
Lehi (2) |
|
74 BC |
|
80 BC |
|
Apostate |
|
Son of Zoram (2) |
|
|
|
Lehi
(3) |
|
|
|
74 BC |
|
|
|
Alma 43-62 |
|
|
|
Military Leader |
|
|
|
Lehi (4) |
|
|
|
45 BC |
|
|
|
(Hel 3:21) |
|
|
|
Younger son of Helaman |
|
Perhaps Lehi would have been mentioned in the Brass Plates, but
he, along with his visions and teachings was included in the Book of Mormon
records. Others may have named their sons Lehi after the First Great leader of
the Nephites, but the record we now have after the time of the coming of the
Savior does not list any. As indicated
in the Chartssome
names were more
popular than others often for obvious reasons.
Some names appear to come from the PLATES OF BRASS. These records were like the Old Testament but
much more extensive (l Ne 13:23). They included much more detail of the events from Adam down to and including
many prophecies of Jeremiah, (l Ne 5:10).
To obtain these plates it required the killing of Laban, a
descendant of Joseph, through his first son Manassah, who had the records at
that time, and apparently employed a scribe to maintain the records and update
them. (l Ne 5:14-16). Lehi was commanded
to take the brass plates with his family to America to maintain both scriptural
and intellectual literacy. (l Ne 3:2-4, 4:13-16, Omni l:17) The Plates of Brass
were a separate record kept by scribes of the 10 tribes, called Israel, or at
least members of Joseph's family. Both
the Jewish record and the Plates of Brass seemed to essentially contain the
same accounts down to about 940 BC, though the Brass Plates were more extensive
and complete. Then Judah under Rehoboam (931-915 BC) separated from
the ten tribes led by Jeroboam l, (931-910 BC), and from then on down until 720,
there were two separate Kingdoms: Judah
and Israel,
and two separate records were kept. When
the Assyrians captured Israel
(The Ten Tribes) under King Hoshea (730-722 BC) the Kingdom of Israel
(the Ten Tribes) vanished. The Kingdom of Judah
continued until the capture of Jerusalem
and King Jehoachin about 600 BC and then the final capture and deportations in
586 BC. After that, dispersions,
returns, and disasters, plagued Judah or the Jews, to the present A few notable additions were made down until
410 BC at which time the official cannon ends until it is taken up by the New
Testament.
Names from before the split into two Kingdoms would be common to
both the Brass Plates and the Old Testament record. After that,
names may have some differences
due to tribal and cultural distinctions and associations with
surrounding
Kingdoms. But there are indications that names were extracted from the
Brass
Plates because the Nephites did not have the Old Testament, but
utilized names from
the records they had in Nephite families.
Perhaps the discussion of one of these names will help clarify the
process. In the year 740 Pekahiah was King, following his father, Mendham,
whose control ended in 741. Pekahiah was the King of Israel, Jotham was then
King of Judah. Note that Pekahiah ends
with the suffix of -iah, which is a hopocoristicon
for Jehovah discussed elsewhere in this series. The name means "Jehovah -(the iah suffix meaning) opens" Pekah
means "Opens" so the name is "Jehovah
Opens". Pekahiah
was murdered at Samaria
(11 Kings 154:23), by the son of a man called Remaliah, that son had the unusual
name of Pekah, without the suffix of
-iah. He did not do Israel any good, and the last King
of Israel, Hoshea, son of Elah, ascended the throne in 732, as the successor of
Pekah. Hoshea had murdered Pekah to get the throne. So
here we have two men with the same name, but one with a descriptive suffix. All of this information would have been in
the Plates of Brass particularly among the portions Nephi and others selected
from the Book of Isaiah to include in the Book of Mormon. In 2 Nephi 17:1 we
read "And it came to pass in the days of Ahaz the sons of Jotham, the son of
Uzziah, King of Judah, that Rezin, king of Syria, and Pekah the son of Remaliah, king of Israel, went up toward Jerusalem
to war against it, but could not prevail against it." Check this account with that in 2 Kings 15:15,
and Isaiah 7. Pekah was of Ephriam, because we learn in verse 2 of 2 Nephi: "Syria
is confederate with Ephriam" (King Pekah).
Pekah was a name used by the Nephites. Your own study can take you from
there. That such an episode turns up in
the Book of Mormon is one that requires a lot of pondering to explain if the
book was the conjured up as the fictional writing of an uneducated young man in
1829, with some expected parallels culled from writings from the Old Testament,
especially of Isaiah.
|
|
CHART 3 |
|
|
SELECTED NAMES FROM BRASS PLATES |
|
AMALAK |
AMMON |
AMOS |
|
In the Book of Mormon we have the following |
|
Amaleki |
Ammon |
Amos |
|
Omni l:12 |
Mos 7:3 |
4 Ne l:19 |
|
130 BC |
121 BC |
150 AD |
|
Record Keeper |
Explorer |
Record Keeper |
|
Amaleki |
Ammon |
Amos |
|
Mos 7:6 |
Mos 27:8 |
4 Ne l:19 |
|
121 BC |
100 BC |
175 AD |
|
Explorer |
Son of Mosiah |
Son of Amos |
|
BENJAMIN |
ENOS |
|
|
Benjamin |
Enos |
|
|
Omni 1:23 |
Jac 7:27 |
|
|
120 BC |
450 BC |
|
|
Prophet/King |
Prophet |
|
|
|
|
|
|
ALSO FROM THE PLATES OF BRASS |
|
GIDEON |
GILGAL |
ISAIAH |
|
Gideon |
Gilgal |
Isaiah |
|
Mos 19:4 |
Mor 6:14 |
3 Ne 19:4 |
|
145 BC |
385 AD |
34 AD |
|
Nephite Patriot |
Nephite Commander |
One of Twelve |
|
|
|
|
|
ISHMAEL |
JACOB |
JEREMIAH |
|
Ishmael |
Jacob |
Jeremiah |
|
l Ne 7:2 |
1 Ne 18:7 |
3 Ne 19:4 |
|
600 BC |
599 BC |
34 AD |
|
Sariah's Brother |
Son of Lehi |
One of the Twelve |
|
|
|
|
|
JONAS |
JOSEPH |
LABON |
|
Jonas |
Joseph |
Laban |
|
3 Ne 19:4 |
l Ne 18:7 |
l Ne 3:3 |
|
34 AD |
595 BC |
600 BC |
|
One of Twelve |
Lehi's son |
Custodian of Brass |
|
|
|
|
|
SAMUEL |
SHEM |
ZEDEKIAH |
|
Samuel |
Shem |
Zedekiah |
|
Hel 13-15 |
Mor 6:14 |
3 Ne 19:4 |
|
6 BC |
385 AD |
34 AD |
|
Lamanite Prophet |
Nephite Military |
One of the Twelve |
|
|
Commander |
|
The above certainly confirms the extent Papponymy occurs in
the Book of Mormon
Now, a few examples from Jaredite Papponymy will continue
the research: Where it was possible, the
number of the person in the posterity of Jared is provided in parenthesis .
So Cohor (10) would
be the tenth descendent of Jared, etc. (see Largey p. 431)
|
|
CHART 4 |
|
|
Cohor Eth 7:15 |
Com Eth 1:16 |
Coriantum Eth 1:17 |
|
Early Jaredite (7) |
Late Jaredite (21) |
Early Jaredite (20) |
|
|
|
|
|
Cohor Eth 7:21 |
Com Eth 1:12 |
Coriantum Eth 1:13 |
|
Son of Cohor (11) |
Late Jaredite (37) |
Middle Jaredite (45) |
|
|
|
|
|
Cohor Eth 13:17 |
Heth
Eth 1:16 |
Coriantumr Eth 7:3 |
|
Late Jaredite |
Early Jaredite (22) |
Early Jaredite (18) |
|
|
|
|
|
Corihor Eth 7:3 |
Heth
Eth 1:15 |
Corianturmr |
|
Early Jaredite
(7) |
Middle Jaredite (33) |
Omni l:21 |
|
|
|
(45) Survivor of
wars. |
|
Corihor
Eth 13:17 |
Shez
Eth 1:14 |
|
|
Late Jaredite
|
Middle Jaredite (23) |
Jared
Eth 1:32 |
|
|
|
Founder Jaredites |
|
Nimrod Eth 2:1 |
Shez |
2359 BC |
|
Grandson of Ham |
Son of Shez (24) |
|
|
|
|
Jared Eth 8:1 |
|
Nimrod
Eth 7:22 |
Lib Eth 1:17 |
Early Jaredite (14) |
|
Son of Cohor (21) |
Middle Jaredite (31) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lib Eth
14:10 |
|
|
|
Late Jaredite (31) |
|
Some of the above names would also have been in the Old
Testament but the Nephites did not have
the Old Testament to draw from, so they must have got them from the Brass
Plates which were more detailed than the Old Testament. As noted above, the
Jaredites also drew from the names of Kings and Cities that they would have
been familiar with at the time of the Tower of Babel.
Nimrod would have been one of those, so would Shem, who was not only alive at
the time the Jaredites left, but lived on until the time of Abraham. But note
the unusual name of Riplakish. It is a
combination of two names, Ripla and Kish. Riplakish
was the twenty-fifth Descendant of Jared.
Kish was the thirtieth. Kish was also one of the names of a great City State contemporary
with Early Dynastic Sumer as well as a King, as mentioned in the Lagash
records... "they mention an ancient occasion of dispute, when a certain
‘Me-salim, King of Kish' had arbitrated between two city
states." (Saggs p. 37) The "power of
early kings of Kish to wield
authority far beyond the borders of their own city-state eventually led to the
title ‘King of Kish', being adopted
by any ruler who claimed over-lordship of Sumer and Akkad." (Saggs p. 37) "The Sumerian King List asserts that after the
Flood kingship was once again ‘Let down from heaven', lighted first upon Kish."
(Saggs p. 27) Kish
was a royal house as well as one of the great cities of Ancient Sumer. (Saggs
p. 29) "Kish, recorded as the First
dynasty after the Flood...indisputably the most important
centre of north Babylonia ....the site of later Babylon...[and the] center of political power."
(Saggs p. 28) The Jaredites originated near Babylon
and near where the tower of Babel was located and it would seem they would have
been very familiar with the House of Kish and the City of Kish and the Kingdom of Kish.
In Ancient Sumerian records "there is a reference to the assembly of the city
of Kish choosing a king as late as
2300 BC; after the Jaredites had left, he took the throne-name of Iphur-kish (‘Kish assembled'). ( Saggs p.
132) A Sumerian Epic "dealing with the siege of Erech (in southern Babylonia)
by the King of Kish shows that
Gilgamesh [taking a name from the Gilgamesh Epic], the ruler of Erech, having
defeated his rival [Kish], neither
put him to death nor humiliated him but showed clemency and returned him to his
own kingdom [to the north]." (Saggs p. 180)
The fifteenth
descendent of Jared was an unnamed daughter who married a man called Akish.
The prefix of -A is evidently a hypocoristicon, a much abbreviated form for Jehovah, to form the
name Akish using the name Kish
as a suffix. This man was not a descendent of Jared, but a man from another
family with the Jaredites. (Eth 1:33) The name Kish had made an impression on the Jaredites
and most likely some of the records they had with them had some historical
information that included this name. Someday
it would be nice to have access to the records of Jared and follow up on
whatever else they may have had to say about Kish.
There will be more to say about Kish
in later studies.
Has anyone else picked up on this interesting name before
this study?
Cross cultural Papponymy is where names are obtained from
one group by another; in this case the Nephites took names found in the records
of the Jaredites and the Brass Plates. A few examples are given:
|
|
CHART 5 |
|
|
Aaron Eth 1:6 |
Noah Eth 7:14 |
Moranton |
|
Jaredite King (34) |
Jaredite King |
Jaredite King (26) |
|
|
Son of Corihor (9) |
|
|
Aaron Mos 17:8 |
Noah Mos 7:9 |
Morianton |
|
Lamanite King |
Nephite King |
Alma 50:28 |
|
|
Founder of City |
Commander |
|
Aaron |
Noah |
Shiblom Eth 1:11 |
|
Biblical |
Biblical |
Late Jaredite King (38) |
|
Exodus 6:16 |
Genesis 5:29 |
Shiblom Mor 6:14 |
|
|
|
Nephite Commander |
Thus, Papponymy
in the Book of Mormon, abundant as it is, is in total agreement with all the
records recovered and translated from the great Mesopotamian sites from the
time of the Jaredites (before 2400 BC) and earliest Semitic beginnings (after
the flood) to the end of the Book of Mormon record.
Recall that the Brass Plates contains a more complete record
from Adam, (4000 BC) down to Jeremiah
(600 BC). All of these histories and
records, though not as detailed, are also in the Jewish record, the Old
Testament. Joseph Smith would have had to have had a super computer to keep all
of this straight without making some ridiculous errors-or he was a prophet, and as he claimed, he was
an instrument in God's hands and with divine assistance brought forth the Book
of Mormon!
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Benson, Elizabeth P., Ed. Dubarton Oaks Conference on the Olmec, Harvard,
Washington, D.C. 1968
Largey, Dennis L., Ed., Book
of Mormon Reference Companion, Deseret Book Co., Salt Lake City, Utah,
2003 McConkie, Joseph F., His
Name Shall be Joseph, Salt Lake
City, Utah, Hawkes
Publishing, Inc., 1980
Porten, Bezalel, Archives
from Elephantine, Berkeley:
University of California Press, 1969
Saggs, H.W.F., The
Babylonians, The Folio Society, London,
1988
|